Disciplinary Hearings and Workplace Discipline under the 2025 Dismissal Code

Master disciplinary hearings, workplace discipline and fair dismissal procedures under South Africa’s 2025 Code of Good Practice on Dismissal.

  • Online – Microsoft Teams
  • 10 -11 November 2026
  • b
    2 CPD Points
  • Price : R 5 999.00
Master disciplinary hearings, workplace discipline and fair dismissal procedures under South Africa’s 2025 Code of Good Practice on Dismissal.

LEARNING OUTCOMES

After successfully completing this course, you will be able to:

Z

Explain the purpose and structure of the 2025 Code of Good Practice: Dismissal

Z

Explain how the Code operates alongside the Labour Relations Act

Z

Evaluate whether a workplace rule or standard can properly support disciplinary action

Z

Distinguish misconduct from incapacity, poor performance and operational-requirements situations

Z

Distinguish a finding of misconduct from the separate question of sanction

Z

Evaluate consistency and parity of treatment

The 2025 Code of Good Practice: Dismissal, what changed and why it matters

  • Publication on 4 September 2025 (Gazette 53294), effective on publication; repeal of Schedule 8 and the separate Code of Good Practice Based on Operational Requirements; one code for misconduct, incapacity and operational requirements
  • The final Code mirrors the draft released for comment on 22 January 2025
  • Status of a Code: guidance that arbitrators and courts apply, general in nature and allowing justified departures; collective agreements remain unaltered and take precedence
  • The philosophy: fairness rather than procedural ritual, dialogue and reflection, proportionate procedures, corrective discipline, and the limits of informality
  • What changed in practice: a move away from court-like procedure and a greater emphasis on a meaningful opportunity to respond. Less formal does not mean less fair
  • Current law versus the 2026 reform proposals, and why proposals must not be presented as enacted law

The fairness test: reason, procedure and the burden of proof 

  • The employee's right not to be unfairly dismissed and the link between section 188 of the Act and the Code
  • What counts as a dismissal, including non-renewal of a fixed-term contract where renewal was reasonably expected, constructive dismissal and refusal to allow a return from maternity leave
  • The three tracks: conduct, capacity and operational requirements
  • Misconduct versus incapacity: "won't do" versus "can't do" as a starting distinction, and the risk of using the wrong procedure
  • Automatically unfair dismissals under section 187, such as protected strike participation, pregnancy and discrimination on prohibited grounds, and why misconduct must not be used as cover for them
  • Burden of proof: in a dismissal that is not automatically unfair, the employer must show a fair reason and a fair procedure, so the record must be built before the dispute arises

Workplace rules, standards and disciplinary codes 

  • When a rule can support discipline: reasonable and valid, known or reasonably knowable, important to the operation, and consistently applied
  • Sources of rules: contracts, policies, codes of conduct, standard operating procedures, safety rules, instructions, collective agreements and bargaining-council requirements
  • Communicating standards: induction, training, written policies, repetition, language and comprehension
  • Grading misconduct: minor, serious and gross, and what zero-tolerance policies can and cannot achieve
  • Small employers: less formal systems are allowed, and the Code gives no definition of a small business. Fairness remains the underlying requirement

Investigating alleged misconduct and precautionary suspension 

  • The purpose of an investigation, and how its depth should match the size of the employer and the seriousness of the allegation
  • Evidence gathering: documents, emails, electronic messages, CCTV, access and attendance records, financial records, witness statements and physical evidence
  • Electronic evidence: authenticity, preservation and any privacy limits (to be confirmed by the reviewer)
  • Preserving evidence: preventing loss, recording sources and keeping a chronology
  • Roles: investigator, complainant, initiator, chairperson and decision-maker, and why they should be kept separate
  • Precautionary suspension: its purpose, why it is not punishment, when it is justified, alternatives, and duration and fairness (Long v South African Breweries, Constitutional Court 2019, to be confirmed by the reviewer)

Charges, notice and preparing for the enquiry 

  • Informing the employee: notification of the alleged misconduct, preferably in writing, with enough detail to read, understand and respond, in a language the employee understands
  • Building an allegation: what happened, when, where, who was involved, which rule was breached and what evidence supports it
  • Common charge defects: vague allegations, several unrelated acts in one charge, wrong classification and charges that do not match the evidence
  • Employee preparation: adequate time, assistance by a fellow employee or union representative, and access to relevant information
  • Hearing preparation: notice, documents, witnesses, venue or technology, chairperson, interpreter and record keeping
  • Formal and informal enquiries: when each is appropriate, and the effect of contract and collective-agreement requirements

Conducting a fair disciplinary enquiry 

  • The purpose: a fair opportunity to respond, clarifying disputed facts, testing the evidence and hearing the employee's version
  • The chairperson: role, impartiality, conflicts of interest, recusal and keeping the enquiry focused
  • A possible structure: opening, allegations, employee response, employer evidence, employee evidence, questions, closing submissions and finding
  • Evidence: relevance, reliability, credibility, hearsay, circumstantial evidence, contradictions, inferences and probabilities
  • Managing difficult hearings: absent employees, postponements, disruption, intimidation, witness problems and delays
  • The principle that anchors the course: a disciplinary enquiry is not a criminal trial

Findings, mitigation and aggravation 

  • Separating guilt from sanction: finding first, sanction second, and no predetermined outcome
  • Making a finding: the allegation, the rule, the supporting and contradicting evidence, and which version is more persuasive and why
  • Recording reasons: clear findings, material evidence, credibility issues, rejected explanations and conclusions
  • Mitigation: length of service, record, personal circumstances, admission of wrongdoing, remorse and prospects of rehabilitation
  • Aggravation: seriousness, harm, position of trust, repetition, deliberate conduct, dishonesty and the effect on the employment relationship
  • Day 1 consolidation: one serious-misconduct scenario run from allegation through investigation, notice, enquiry and evidence to a finding

Sanction, proportionality and progressive discipline 

  • A finding of misconduct does not automatically mean dismissal: the sanction is a separate decision
  • The Code's sanction factors: the rule breached and its validity, the employee's knowledge of it, its importance, the harm caused, consistent application, and whether dismissal is appropriate
  • When dismissal is appropriate: where continued employment has become intolerable, taking into account the job, the seriousness and effect of the misconduct, and whether progressive discipline could work
  • Personal circumstances: length of service, disciplinary record and the consequences of dismissal
  • Progressive discipline: its purpose, warnings and final warnings, and when it may be inappropriate
  • First-offence dismissal: certain misconduct, such as theft, assault or gross dishonesty, may justify it, and circumstances in which it would still be disproportionate

Consistency, parity and comparable cases 

  • The general rule: employees involved in similar misconduct in similar circumstances should receive comparable sanctions
  • The Code's qualification: dismissal may still be fair where the misconduct irreparably damages the employment relationship, even if earlier cases were treated differently
  • Finding a genuine comparator: same or similar misconduct, similar circumstances, seriousness, responsibility and relevant personal factors
  • When different sanctions can be justified: severity, role, personal circumstances, disciplinary record, consequences, evidence and effect on the relationship
  • Managing the risk: search historical records, identify comparators and document the reasons for any difference
  • Exercise: two employees, the same incident, different sanctions. Is the difference defensible?

Incapacity and the wrong-track problem 

  • How the Code groups incapacity: ill-health and injury, poor performance, incompatibility (item 21(7)) and imprisonment
  • Ill-health and injury: assess severity and cause, explore alternatives, consult, let the employee present their case with assistance, and consider adapted duties or alternative employment for permanent incapacity
  • Work-related illness and injury: a more onerous duty to accommodate, and the link to return-to-work duties under COIDA
  • Poor performance: standards, communication of expectations, guidance and opportunity to improve; a warning may not be needed for managers, senior employees and highly skilled professionals
  • Incompatibility: dismissal only where the problem is severe enough to cause an irretrievable breakdown, with the same fairness requirements
  • Imprisonment as a ground of incapacity, and why classification decides the process

Probation, unprotected strikes and small employers 

  • Probation: a reasonable period set in advance, reasonable guidance and evaluation, and a chance to make representations before non-confirmation
  • The standard of reasons for non-confirmation during probation, and the warning that using probation to avoid permanent status may be an unfair dismissal
  • Unprotected strikes: notify the union or representatives, engage, issue a clear ultimatum and allow reasonable time to comply; relevant factors include the seriousness of the illegality, attempts to comply, employer provocation and individual circumstances
  • Small employers: simpler procedures are permitted as long as the core requirement of fairness is met

After the hearing: outcome, appeals and records 

  • The outcome: finding, sanction, effective date and reasons, communicated in a clear letter that does not contradict itself
  • Appeals: what the employer's own policy, a collective agreement or the contract provides, since the Code does not require one
  • The disciplinary file should let a reviewer follow: what happened, what was alleged, what evidence existed, what process was followed, what the employee said, what was found and why the sanction was imposed
  • Warnings: written and final written warnings, their duration, expiry under the disciplinary code and use in later hearings
  • The first 30 days after a dismissal: preserving records, CCMA preparation, internal review, payroll and HR administration, and retrieving comparator cases
  • Conduct that creates a constructive-dismissal risk

The CCMA, bargaining councils and dispute risk 

  • When a dismissal becomes a dispute: unfair dismissal, procedural and substantive unfairness and automatically unfair dismissal
  • Referral: 30 days from the date of dismissal for unfair dismissal disputes and 90 days for unfair labour practice disputes; condonation for late referrals; bargaining-council jurisdiction
  • Conciliation, arbitration and con-arb, which is mandatory for dismissals during probation
  • What the employer must prove: a fair reason, a fair procedure, evidence supporting the decision and an appropriate sanction
  • Remedies: reinstatement, re-employment or compensation (section 193); compensation of up to 12 months' remuneration, and up to 24 months for an automatically unfair dismissal; compensation where the only defect is procedural
  • The disciplinary file as the employer's defence: if the process cannot be reconstructed from the file, the employer may struggle to defend it
  • Proposals in the 2026 bills, kept separate from current law (see the table later in this specification)