Disciplinary Hearings and Workplace Discipline under the 2025 Dismissal Code
Master disciplinary hearings, workplace discipline and fair dismissal procedures under South Africa’s 2025 Code of Good Practice on Dismissal.
- Online – Microsoft Teams
- 10 -11 November 2026
- 2 CPD Points
- Price : R 5 999.00

LEARNING OUTCOMES
After successfully completing this course, you will be able to:
Explain the purpose and structure of the 2025 Code of Good Practice: Dismissal
Explain how the Code operates alongside the Labour Relations Act
Evaluate whether a workplace rule or standard can properly support disciplinary action
Distinguish misconduct from incapacity, poor performance and operational-requirements situations
Distinguish a finding of misconduct from the separate question of sanction
Evaluate consistency and parity of treatment
The 2025 Code of Good Practice: Dismissal, what changed and why it matters
- Publication on 4 September 2025 (Gazette 53294), effective on publication; repeal of Schedule 8 and the separate Code of Good Practice Based on Operational Requirements; one code for misconduct, incapacity and operational requirements
- The final Code mirrors the draft released for comment on 22 January 2025
- Status of a Code: guidance that arbitrators and courts apply, general in nature and allowing justified departures; collective agreements remain unaltered and take precedence
- The philosophy: fairness rather than procedural ritual, dialogue and reflection, proportionate procedures, corrective discipline, and the limits of informality
- What changed in practice: a move away from court-like procedure and a greater emphasis on a meaningful opportunity to respond. Less formal does not mean less fair
- Current law versus the 2026 reform proposals, and why proposals must not be presented as enacted law
The fairness test: reason, procedure and the burden of proof
- The employee's right not to be unfairly dismissed and the link between section 188 of the Act and the Code
- What counts as a dismissal, including non-renewal of a fixed-term contract where renewal was reasonably expected, constructive dismissal and refusal to allow a return from maternity leave
- The three tracks: conduct, capacity and operational requirements
- Misconduct versus incapacity: "won't do" versus "can't do" as a starting distinction, and the risk of using the wrong procedure
- Automatically unfair dismissals under section 187, such as protected strike participation, pregnancy and discrimination on prohibited grounds, and why misconduct must not be used as cover for them
- Burden of proof: in a dismissal that is not automatically unfair, the employer must show a fair reason and a fair procedure, so the record must be built before the dispute arises
Workplace rules, standards and disciplinary codes
- When a rule can support discipline: reasonable and valid, known or reasonably knowable, important to the operation, and consistently applied
- Sources of rules: contracts, policies, codes of conduct, standard operating procedures, safety rules, instructions, collective agreements and bargaining-council requirements
- Communicating standards: induction, training, written policies, repetition, language and comprehension
- Grading misconduct: minor, serious and gross, and what zero-tolerance policies can and cannot achieve
- Small employers: less formal systems are allowed, and the Code gives no definition of a small business. Fairness remains the underlying requirement
Investigating alleged misconduct and precautionary suspension
- The purpose of an investigation, and how its depth should match the size of the employer and the seriousness of the allegation
- Evidence gathering: documents, emails, electronic messages, CCTV, access and attendance records, financial records, witness statements and physical evidence
- Electronic evidence: authenticity, preservation and any privacy limits (to be confirmed by the reviewer)
- Preserving evidence: preventing loss, recording sources and keeping a chronology
- Roles: investigator, complainant, initiator, chairperson and decision-maker, and why they should be kept separate
- Precautionary suspension: its purpose, why it is not punishment, when it is justified, alternatives, and duration and fairness (Long v South African Breweries, Constitutional Court 2019, to be confirmed by the reviewer)
Charges, notice and preparing for the enquiry
- Informing the employee: notification of the alleged misconduct, preferably in writing, with enough detail to read, understand and respond, in a language the employee understands
- Building an allegation: what happened, when, where, who was involved, which rule was breached and what evidence supports it
- Common charge defects: vague allegations, several unrelated acts in one charge, wrong classification and charges that do not match the evidence
- Employee preparation: adequate time, assistance by a fellow employee or union representative, and access to relevant information
- Hearing preparation: notice, documents, witnesses, venue or technology, chairperson, interpreter and record keeping
- Formal and informal enquiries: when each is appropriate, and the effect of contract and collective-agreement requirements
Conducting a fair disciplinary enquiry
- The purpose: a fair opportunity to respond, clarifying disputed facts, testing the evidence and hearing the employee's version
- The chairperson: role, impartiality, conflicts of interest, recusal and keeping the enquiry focused
- A possible structure: opening, allegations, employee response, employer evidence, employee evidence, questions, closing submissions and finding
- Evidence: relevance, reliability, credibility, hearsay, circumstantial evidence, contradictions, inferences and probabilities
- Managing difficult hearings: absent employees, postponements, disruption, intimidation, witness problems and delays
- The principle that anchors the course: a disciplinary enquiry is not a criminal trial
Findings, mitigation and aggravation
- Separating guilt from sanction: finding first, sanction second, and no predetermined outcome
- Making a finding: the allegation, the rule, the supporting and contradicting evidence, and which version is more persuasive and why
- Recording reasons: clear findings, material evidence, credibility issues, rejected explanations and conclusions
- Mitigation: length of service, record, personal circumstances, admission of wrongdoing, remorse and prospects of rehabilitation
- Aggravation: seriousness, harm, position of trust, repetition, deliberate conduct, dishonesty and the effect on the employment relationship
- Day 1 consolidation: one serious-misconduct scenario run from allegation through investigation, notice, enquiry and evidence to a finding
Sanction, proportionality and progressive discipline
- A finding of misconduct does not automatically mean dismissal: the sanction is a separate decision
- The Code's sanction factors: the rule breached and its validity, the employee's knowledge of it, its importance, the harm caused, consistent application, and whether dismissal is appropriate
- When dismissal is appropriate: where continued employment has become intolerable, taking into account the job, the seriousness and effect of the misconduct, and whether progressive discipline could work
- Personal circumstances: length of service, disciplinary record and the consequences of dismissal
- Progressive discipline: its purpose, warnings and final warnings, and when it may be inappropriate
- First-offence dismissal: certain misconduct, such as theft, assault or gross dishonesty, may justify it, and circumstances in which it would still be disproportionate
Consistency, parity and comparable cases
- The general rule: employees involved in similar misconduct in similar circumstances should receive comparable sanctions
- The Code's qualification: dismissal may still be fair where the misconduct irreparably damages the employment relationship, even if earlier cases were treated differently
- Finding a genuine comparator: same or similar misconduct, similar circumstances, seriousness, responsibility and relevant personal factors
- When different sanctions can be justified: severity, role, personal circumstances, disciplinary record, consequences, evidence and effect on the relationship
- Managing the risk: search historical records, identify comparators and document the reasons for any difference
- Exercise: two employees, the same incident, different sanctions. Is the difference defensible?
Incapacity and the wrong-track problem
- How the Code groups incapacity: ill-health and injury, poor performance, incompatibility (item 21(7)) and imprisonment
- Ill-health and injury: assess severity and cause, explore alternatives, consult, let the employee present their case with assistance, and consider adapted duties or alternative employment for permanent incapacity
- Work-related illness and injury: a more onerous duty to accommodate, and the link to return-to-work duties under COIDA
- Poor performance: standards, communication of expectations, guidance and opportunity to improve; a warning may not be needed for managers, senior employees and highly skilled professionals
- Incompatibility: dismissal only where the problem is severe enough to cause an irretrievable breakdown, with the same fairness requirements
- Imprisonment as a ground of incapacity, and why classification decides the process
Probation, unprotected strikes and small employers
- Probation: a reasonable period set in advance, reasonable guidance and evaluation, and a chance to make representations before non-confirmation
- The standard of reasons for non-confirmation during probation, and the warning that using probation to avoid permanent status may be an unfair dismissal
- Unprotected strikes: notify the union or representatives, engage, issue a clear ultimatum and allow reasonable time to comply; relevant factors include the seriousness of the illegality, attempts to comply, employer provocation and individual circumstances
- Small employers: simpler procedures are permitted as long as the core requirement of fairness is met
After the hearing: outcome, appeals and records
- The outcome: finding, sanction, effective date and reasons, communicated in a clear letter that does not contradict itself
- Appeals: what the employer's own policy, a collective agreement or the contract provides, since the Code does not require one
- The disciplinary file should let a reviewer follow: what happened, what was alleged, what evidence existed, what process was followed, what the employee said, what was found and why the sanction was imposed
- Warnings: written and final written warnings, their duration, expiry under the disciplinary code and use in later hearings
- The first 30 days after a dismissal: preserving records, CCMA preparation, internal review, payroll and HR administration, and retrieving comparator cases
- Conduct that creates a constructive-dismissal risk
The CCMA, bargaining councils and dispute risk
- When a dismissal becomes a dispute: unfair dismissal, procedural and substantive unfairness and automatically unfair dismissal
- Referral: 30 days from the date of dismissal for unfair dismissal disputes and 90 days for unfair labour practice disputes; condonation for late referrals; bargaining-council jurisdiction
- Conciliation, arbitration and con-arb, which is mandatory for dismissals during probation
- What the employer must prove: a fair reason, a fair procedure, evidence supporting the decision and an appropriate sanction
- Remedies: reinstatement, re-employment or compensation (section 193); compensation of up to 12 months' remuneration, and up to 24 months for an automatically unfair dismissal; compensation where the only defect is procedural
- The disciplinary file as the employer's defence: if the process cannot be reconstructed from the file, the employer may struggle to defend it
- Proposals in the 2026 bills, kept separate from current law (see the table later in this specification)
